Wandering
Posted by Jordan on March 5, 2009
For Lent at COTA this year a man in our parish is teaching a class on prayer entitled Great Arguments with God. Last night we examined Jacob’s all night wrestling match with God. To aid us in this exploratation we read from Frederick Beuchner’s The Son of Laughter. In it Beuchner retells Jacob’s encounter with God in dramatic fashion. What Beuchner reveals in his retelling is how Jacob really didn’t know who he was wrestling with or even why he was wrestling until the night was over. Jacob’s confusion struck a cord with me, especially as we reflected upon prayer and fighting with God.
It is easy to be energized by an argument or fight if one knows what it is they are fighting for. We see this in other scriptural accounts where people argued with God because God was clearly in the wrong, or it was quite obvious that God needed to do something (i.e. “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?). But what about when you are striving with God or life, or whatever, but you really don’t know why.
I find this scenario more common for my own spiritual journey. Wrestling in the dark with the unknown, wandering through the desert with no destination. I’m told there is a promise, or blessing out there somewhere, but the fact that it is out there, fails to make the present any clearer.
Lex said
Why does Beuchner believe that Jacob didn’t know why he wrestled with God until morning? Just curious.
Do you think in those other scriptural accounts, people argued with God because God was wrong, or because God was giving them an opportunity to work with Him?
Jordan said
I think Beuchner was trying to imagine what it would have been like. You should check out the book, Son of Laughter.
As for your second question, for me in order for God to be God does not require God to fit all sorts of different categories, omnipotence, omniscience, omni-presence, etc… So I don’t really have any qualms about calling God to account, or allowing people in scripture to do so as well.
Thanks for your thoughts.